Imposter Syndrome and Self-Confidence: When You've Always Felt Like the Weird One
Think about the last time you were around a group of people and tried change or hide something about yourself. Maybe you toned down a joke because it was a little odd or off color. Maybe you agreed with an opinion someone had just so you don't have to justify yourself, or told a story differently than it happened because the real version made you feel like you sounded a bit "crazy." Most of us do some version of this at different points in our days, but sometimes, you can do it so much, it just becomes the norm.

Now say someone tells you that you're really good at what you do. If you've spent years hiding or changing parts of yourself around other people, a compliment usually doesn't feel good for long. Another thought shows up: they only think that because they haven't seen the real me. That thought is the beginnings of what we'll call imposter syndrome.
What Is Imposter Syndrome, and Is It a Real Diagnosis?
Imposter syndrome means believing you're less capable or less deserving than other people think you are, even when there's evidence saying otherwise. Mental health professionals treat it as a common pattern that's underlain with other struggles and not an official diagnosis. It often shows up along with anxiety, perfectionism, burnout, and people pleasing.
The term "imposter syndrome" comes from psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes, who described it in 1978 after seeing it in women with strong careers. Researchers have since found it in pretty much the whole spectrum of humanity; men, women, teens, professionals and so on. Since it shows up in so many groups, plenty of people who seem sure of themselves are probably wondering whether they belong too.
Why the "Weird One" Often Feels Like a Fraud
Plenty of adults who feel like frauds remember being the odd kid. They liked different things, got more intense about stuff than their friends did, or grew up in a family they may have done things differently from the neighbors. At some point they got laughed at or left out for being different, and they figured out how to prevent that embarrassment from happening again. They watched what other people did and copied it.
Therapists and researchers call this masking, which just means hiding or changing parts of yourself so people will accept you. It works and that is unfortunately a big part of the problem. People begin to like the version you show them. They tell you how great you are and ask you to hang out. But you know that this version is just a filter, so the positivity feels like it's meant for somebody else. Over time you start to believe that if people met the real you, they'd feel differently, that they really won't like you at all.
That's why someone can be good at what they do and still feel like a fraud. They know their skills are real, and they still feel like the person getting complimented isn't actually them.
What Self-Confidence Actually Means
Most people picture a confident person as someone who's comfortable anywhere, good at small talk, and easy with strangers. But someone who's very good at reading a room and matching it can look exactly like that while feeling incredibly anxious the entire time, keeping track of everyone's reactions.
Self-confidence means being able to show people who you actually are, including the odd or potentially unpopular parts, and being okay when some people don't respond as positively as you'd hope. Being yourself doesn't mean acting the same everywhere. You'll speak and act differently at a funeral than at a wedding and still be the same person at both. Someone striving for approval keeps changing what they say they think and feel to match the room, because it feels safe, not because it's the right context to be different.
Think about the friend everyone calls when something goes wrong. They're warm, reliable, and virtually always available. They've never told the group they hate the restaurant everyone keeps picking, and when they're having a hard time, it stays unmentioned because they expect everyone else will be annoyed with whatever they might need. So when somebody says, "I don't know what I'd do without you," their first thought is that the group would miss the helper, but nobody would actually miss them.
The friend everyone calls isn't the only person who hides what they think. Take the sibling who keeps the peace at every family holiday by agreeing with everyone, or the partner who hasn't said what they want for dinner in years. The situations differ, but the belief underneath is the same: the real me wouldn't be wanted.
Why Compliments Can Make It Worse
Praise is supposed to help. If you've been hiding parts of yourself each compliment adds more and more pressure, because now you've got a reputation to protect. The better things go, the more you have to lose, and the more exhausting it gets to keep everything up. That's why a lot of people feel completely wiped out after a night out that was actually fun.
You also end up explaining the praise away. If a friend says you were great company last night, or if someone loves a dish you cooked, you feel like they were probably just being nice. Every time, the compliment gets credited to luck or good manners, so it never counts toward the idea that people actually like you.
Is It Low Confidence or Low Self-Esteem?
People often mix up confidence and self-esteem. Confidence is believing you can do things, like cook a good dinner or handle a tough conversation, while self-esteem is how much you value yourself as a person. Imposter syndrome looks like low confidence, because you doubt your skills even when your results very much show you're perfectly competent. Another success or another compliment rarely makes the doubt go away. When a doubt still sticks around in the face of that much evidence, it usually comes from how you value yourself as a person. If you believe people only like a curated version of you, you'll have trouble trusting anything good they say about you, including their opinion of your skills. Proving yourself again won't settle the doubt.
What If You Really Don't Fit In?
Sometimes you really don't fit in with the people around you. Maybe your friends care about things you have no interest in, or you're one of the only people with your background at your school. Studies have found stronger imposter feelings among people from groups that are underrepresented in their setting, such as ethnic minority students and women in science fields. A lower sense of belonging also goes along with stronger imposter feelings. When that's your situation, part of the discomfort comes from the setting, and nothing is actually wrong with you. In a setting that doesn't fit you, feeling out of place can be a reasonable reaction. Finding even a few people who share your interests or values usually makes it much easier to feel like you can just be yourself without the massive effort to fit in.
How to Build Self-Confidence Without Changing Who You Are
Start with small things. Pick the restaurant you'd actually want. Say what you honestly thought about a movie. Tell someone you're excited about something, and show them how excited you really are.
Then see what what happens. Most people never test their fears of being rejected, because the fear keeps them from trying. Write down what you said and how people reacted. After a few weeks you'll have real examples to compare against the belief that the real you would get shunned.
Along with keeping track of how people react, it helps to tell one person how you've been feeling. Imposter feelings last longer when you keep them private, and thinking you're the only one who has them makes it worse. Pick someone you trust and tell them something you usually hide, like how often you feel like a fraud or how much you change around other people. There's a good chance they'll validate you and might even tell you their own anxiety in return.
Lastly, and unfortunately, expect a little disappointment. When you show people the real you, a few will react with less acceptance than the edited version of yourself got. Self-confidence includes accepting and dealing with that in a healthy way. Losing a friendship that only worked while you were editing yourself hurts, especially if it's a long relationship, but it also leaves you more time and energy for people who like the real you.
Imposter syndrome and feeling like the weird one come from the same belief, that who you are has to be changed before people will accept it. Self-confidence grows as you test that belief and find out how many people respond well to the real you. Your skills and achievements stay exactly the same the whole time. The difference is that the person getting the compliment is actually you.
One last note, a lot of people that deal with imposter syndrome come into therapy, and when asked "who they are" when they aren't trying to mask, they just shrug their shoulders and say, "I have no clue and don't know how to figure it out." If you're feeling like you don't even know where to begin, maybe it's time to reach out for some professional guidance. Book a free 15-minute consultation.
More Suggested Blog Posts: Why High-Achievers Feel Like Frauds, Moving Past External Validation, The High Cost of Perfection
Written By Hunter Cook, LPC/MHSP (S)




Comments